8/10 Good
Jonathan V., Tampa, Florida
May 4, 2025
Quaint
We loved the charm of the old Florida cottage feel, but unfortunately, this stay missed the mark for us. The house was surface-level clean, but furniture, towels, and linens had a strong stale smell that lingered on clothes. The beds were extremely thin and firm—uncomfortable to the point of pain—and the metal frames squeaked constantly. The pillows weren’t much better. I ended up on the couch, which was slightly more comfortable despite the same stale smell. The pool area was also disappointing, with worn-out chairs and poor upkeep. We usually love staying in the Cudjoe area, but sadly, we won’t rebook this listing. With a few updates, though, it could be much more enjoyable.
Jonathan V.
Stayed 2 nights in May 2025