
Book Cheap American Airlines flight from New York (JFK) to Key West (EYW) from CA $803
Find The Best Day to Book a Cheap American Airlines Flights From New York to Key West
Cheapest American Airlines Flights from New York (JFK) to Key West (EYW)
The cheapest flights to Key West Intl. found within the past 7 days were CA $1,037 round trip and CA $803 one way. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Frequently asked questions
Grab a great American Airlines flight from JFK to EYW
To find a great deal on American Airlines flights with Travelocity, simply enter your origin and destination airports, pick your travel dates, and hit search. From here, you can sort by price, flight duration, and arrival/departure time. You can also filter to find nonstop flights.
Flying American Airlines New York to Key West gives you fights to choose from. With that direct flight time of , you’ll be touching down before you know it.
Find cheap flights with American Airlines between New York and Key West
American Airlines has a range of great fares on stacks of flights, and to find the most affordable for you, there are a few tricks you can try. Booking in advance, for example, is a great way to grab a fantastic deal. Also, choose the cheapest month, if you can. One-way flights from New York to Key West with American Airlines are December.
The more flexible you are, the more affordable flights you’re likely to find. Consider one-way flights and connecting flights, as well as standard roundtrip and direct options. Even if you’re flying today, cheap last-minute flights are easy to find by entering your travel dates and hitting search.
Reasons to book your American Airlines flights with Travelocity
Travelocity makes it easy to book a seat, anywhere in the world. The vast inventory, fast search, and advanced filters put some of the best deals on the planet in one place. Whether you’re traveling on business, with friends, family, or on your own, take your pick from some fantastic options. And with free cancellation and pay later options, you can travel more and worry less.
Airport code | Country | Airport name | Number of flights |
|---|---|---|---|
| DFW | USA | Dallas-Fort Worth Intl. | 599 |
| CLT | USA | Charlotte-Douglas Intl. | 536 |
| ORD | USA | O'Hare Intl. | 317 |
| PHL | USA | Philadelphia Intl. | 247 |
| MIA | USA | Miami Intl. | 193 |
| DCA | USA | Ronald Reagan Washington National | 152 |
| PHX | USA | Sky Harbor Intl. | 141 |
| LAX | USA | Los Angeles Intl. | 81 |
| LGA | USA | LaGuardia | 72 |
| BOS | USA | Logan Intl. | 57 |
Travelers ❤️ these 🏨 after their flight to Key West

Hyatt Vacation Club at Windward Pointe, Key West
N
Reviewed on Dec 7, 2025

Hampton Inn Key West FL
Breakfast could have better healthy options
Reviewed on Dec 7, 2025

DoubleTree Resort by Hilton Grand Key - Key West
Our Birthday Club recently stayed at the resort while in town celebrating our Sister Audrey's 60th Birthday. The resort staff were very friendly and accommodating. The front desk team were helpful, the shuttle drivers were friendly and went the extra mile to make sure we got to our destinations, ...
Reviewed on Dec 8, 2025
Want more than a(n) American Airlines Flight from New York to Key West?
Popular American Airlines Flight Routes from JFK
Domestic
- Toronto to Fort Lauderdale (YYZ - FLL)
- Toronto to Miami (YYZ - MIA)
- Toronto to Mexico City (YYZ - MEX)
- Toronto to Mumbai (YYZ - BOM)
- Toronto to New York (YYZ - JFK)
- Toronto to Los Angeles (YYZ - LAX)
- Montreal to Paris (YUL - CDG)
- Montreal to Cancun (YUL - CUN)
- Toronto to Orlando (YYZ - MCO)
- Toronto to New York (YYZ - LGA)
International
- Montreal to Paris (YUL - CDG)
- Vancouver to Delhi (YVR - DEL)
- Toronto to Las Vegas (YYZ - LAS)
- Toronto to Karachi (YYZ - KHI)
- Toronto to Fort Lauderdale (YYZ - FLL)
- Toronto to Mumbai (YYZ - BOM)
- Montreal to Miami (YUL - MIA)
- Toronto to Los Angeles (YYZ - LAX)
- Toronto to New York (YYZ - JFK)
- Montreal to Cancun (YUL - CUN)
Most Popular
- YYZ - MCO
- Swoop Hamilton (YHM) to St. Petersburg - Clearwater (PIE) flights
- WestJet Edmonton (YEG) to Orlando (MCO) flights
- YUL - FLL
- YYZ - SRQ
- YYZ - TPA
- DTW - MCO
- BUF - JFK
- YYZ - PIE
- Air Canada Toronto (YYZ) to Orlando (MCO) flights
- YYZ - MIA
- BUF - MYR
- YYZ - RSW
- FLL - YYZ
- Spirit Airlines Niagara Falls (IAG) to Myrtle Beach (MYR) flights
- JetBlue Airways Buffalo (BUF) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL) flights
- BUF - MCO
- Swoop Hamilton (YHM) to Sanford (SFB) flights
- MCO - YYZ
- BUF - BNA
- YHZ - MCO
- YVR - MCO
- Air Canada Montreal (YUL) to Orlando (MCO) flights
- DTW - TPA
- YYZ - LGA
- YYT - MCO
- Air Canada Toronto (YYZ) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL) flights
- Flair Airlines Toronto (YYZ) to Miami (MIA) flights
- DTW - MIA
- YYZ - ECP
