Book a hotel near Gilbert Lake State Park, New York

"Great place to say for our trip to Dreams Park. "

"We were very impressed with our stay and Matt was a great Host. The breakfasts were delicious and was a great way to start the day. Matt also made great suggestions about what to do and eat in the area."

"We had a good time!"

"Beautiful, serene and unique! The perfect getaway to relax and unwind. My husband and I stayed 4 nights with our dog and enjoyed every moment. The property is incredibly private and makes you feel like you're in your own secluded garden. The house is so unique and very cool to think on how old the building is and that it was once a working grist mill. It was a perfect blend of the old and modern. Robert has obviously put a lot of thought into making this a comfortable home, with many personal touches throughout. And a hammock? Inside? Now that was pretty great. Communication with Robert was above and beyond. We hope to stay again! "

"We absolutely loved our stay! This was by far the cleanest of the three VRBOs we stayed in during our New York trip. The house was spotless, well cared for, and had a lot of thoughtful touches—including some welcome treats and fun games for the kids.The host was incredibly friendly and responsive, making the entire experience smooth and stress-free. The neighborhood was cute, quiet, and felt very safe—perfect for families.We’d absolutely stay here again. Highly recommend to anyone coming for a Cooperstown baseball tournament or just visiting the area!"

"Very run down property in middle of nowhere. No proper locks, dirty, inconveniently located and NO lake anywhere in sight. Owner lives in trailer a few lots down and was showering in garage when I arrived. I immediately felt unsafe and creeped out and left the property. Be prepared to have no cell service once you leave the door. I had to find a hotel to stay in because it was such a nightmare of a place. One wall AC unit inbedroom for entire home.Currently in duspute for a complete refund as this VRBO was not suitable for a stay! "