Cheap Flight Deals to Fire Island NY from CA $214

Wander Wisely with exceptional service, 24/7 supportOpens in a new window

Feel at ease with free flight cancellations within 24 hours of booking

Change your flight without a fee on select flights

How to find cheap flights to Fire Island?

The cheapest prices found with in the last 7 days for return flights were CA $134 and CA $214 for one-way flights to Fire Island for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply

Wed, Sep 23 - Tue, Sep 29
YYZ
Pearson Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
CA $349 Roundtrip, found 5 days ago
CA $349
Roundtrip
found 5 days ago
Select Delta flight, departing Wed, Sep 23 from Pearson Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Tue, Sep 29, priced at CA $349 found 5 days ago
OriginDestinationTravel datesFlights from*
MIANew YorkMay 5 to May 9CA $134
ATLNew YorkApril 28 to May 2CA $162
ATLNewarkMay 7 to May 13CA $173
MCONew YorkMay 21 to May 28CA $237
SJUNew YorkApril 25 to April 29CA $241
ATLNew YorkMay 7 to May 13CA $245
TPANewarkMay 13 to May 17CA $249
FLLNew YorkMay 13 to May 17CA $265
LAXNewarkMay 28 to June 6CA $267
PBINew YorkApril 27 to April 30CA $292
LAXNew YorkApril 29 to April 29CA $340
SFONew YorkMay 8 to May 8CA $370
LAXNew YorkApril 24 to April 28CA $373
SFONew YorkMay 5 to May 12CA $476
FCONew YorkMay 13 to May 17CA $1,041
*Prices include taxes and fees
OriginDestinationTravel datesFlights from*
ATLNewarkApril 17 to April 22CA $305
MIANewarkApril 17 to April 18CA $305
ATLNew YorkApril 17 to April 22CA $425
MIANew YorkApril 17 to April 19CA $440
SFONew YorkApril 18 to April 29CA $575
ATLNew YorkApril 17 to April 19CA $704
FCONew YorkApril 19 to May 2CA $753
SFONewarkApril 18 to June 7CA $787
SFONew YorkApril 18 to April 29CA $788
LAXNewarkApril 17 to April 19CA $804
LAXNew YorkApril 17 to April 19CA $994
LAXNew YorkApril 17 to April 19CA $1,144
FCONew YorkApril 19 to April 23CA $1,183
FCONewarkApril 19 to April 23CA $1,311
*Prices include taxes and fees

Your guide to flights to Fire Island, NY

Air Canada, Delta fly to Fire Island, so use Travelocity to search, find, and compare some truly tempting deals from the 2 airlines—that way you can be sure you’ve found the best deal for you. A flight to Fire Island NY currently costs between CA $134 and CA $1,311. Prices vary, but for the best fares, travel in May when prices are at their lowest.  

Top tips for finding cheap flights to Fire Island  

The cheapest flight for a round trip to Fire Island is currently CA $134. When you search for flights to Fire Island, enter your preferred travel dates then click on ‘flexible dates’ to compare cheap flight tickets to Fire Island for nearby days.  The cheapest month to travel to Fire Island is September from our list of deals available.  

But if you’re flexible about when you travel, you can find great deals on flights across the year. If you’re planning a vacation, you can save more on Travelocity when you bundle flights with car rental and hotel bookings, too. Many airlines currently offer flexible booking options, so look for flights offering no change fees.   

How to cancel flights to Fire Island 

We know plans change, that’s why at Travelocity, we make it as easy as possible for you to cancel or amend your plane tickets. Go to My Trips, enter your itinerary number, then follow the instructions. Many airlines let you cancel flights online free of charge if you booked it in the last 24 hours. Visit Customer Service for more advice.  

Why you should book your flight to Fire Island with Travelocity 

We have top deals on plane tickets even for last minute flights to Fire Island, so you can simply type in your travel dates and compare our best prices. Booking with Travelocity means you get flexible cancellation options, 24/7 support, and, thanks to our Price Match Promise, if the airfare drops after you book, you can get a refund! Whether you’re planning a business trip, weekend getaway, or a family vacation—let Travelocity get you to Fire Island for less. 

Find The Perfect Hotel For After Your Flight

Family Friendly Hotels in Fire Island

Clegg's Hotel

Clegg's Hotel

3 out of 5
478 Bayberry Walk Ocean Beach NY
Book a stay at this family-friendly hotel in Ocean Beach. Enjoy free breakfast, free WiFi, and room service. Popular attractions Ocean Beach and Atlantique Beach ...
8/10 Very Good! (196 reviews)
Overpriced
Way too expensive for the condition of the hotel. Location is good. Called them three times over three days to provide information they requested. I never received a call back from any of the three messages I left.

Reviewed on Sep 14, 2025

Get rates
Opens in a new windowClegg's Hotel
The Fire Island Beach House

The Fire Island Beach House

2.5 out of 5
25 Cayuga Walk Bay Shore NY
Book a stay at this beach hotel in Bay Shore. Enjoy an outdoor pool, a beach locale, and breakfast (surcharge). Popular attractions Ocean Beach and Sunken Forest ...
Get rates
Opens in a new windowThe Fire Island Beach House
The Palms Hotel Fire Island

The Palms Hotel Fire Island

3.5 out of 5
168 Cottage Walk Ocean Beach NY
The price is CA $593 per night from May 16 to May 17
CA $593
CA $760 total
May 16 - May 17
includes taxes & fees
Stay at this hotel in Ocean Beach. Enjoy free breakfast, free WiFi, and room service. Popular attractions Ocean Beach and Atlantique Beach are located ...
7.8/10 Good! (177 reviews)
The staff was amazing.

Reviewed on Dec 22, 2025

Opens in a new windowThe Palms Hotel Fire Island
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Best Fire Island Flight and Hotel Packages

Fire Island flight + hotel packages - economy flights

Price found within the past 48 hours. Click for updated prices.
Interfaith 21

Interfaith 21

2 out of 5
Price was CA $1,800, price is now CA $1,131 per person
CA $1,131
per person
Jun 11 - Jun 14
found 1 day ago
Roundtrip flight included
Toronto (YYZ) to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR)
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

5 out of 5
Price was CA $3,712, price is now CA $2,424 per person
CA $2,424
per person
May 15 - May 18
found 10 hours ago
Roundtrip flight included
Halifax (YHZ) to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR)
Hotel BPM - Brooklyn New York

Hotel BPM - Brooklyn New York

2 out of 5
Price was CA $2,058, price is now CA $1,291 per person
CA $1,291
per person
May 23 - May 30
found 1 day ago
Roundtrip flight included
Toronto (YYZ) to New York (JFK)
Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available trips from Toronto to Fire Island
View all trips

Need a car after flight to Fire Island?

Economy

Chevrolet Spark or similar
  • 4 people
Chevrolet Spark
Economy Chevrolet Spark

Compact

Ford Focus or similar
  • 4 people
Ford Focus
Compact Ford Focus

Midsize

Toyota Corolla or similar
  • 5 people
Toyota Corolla
Midsize Toyota Corolla

SUV

Jeep Compass or similar
  • 5 people
Jeep Compass
SUV Jeep Compass

Frequently asked questions

Can I fly to Fire Island right now?
Before making arrangements, have a read through our Covid-19 Travel Advisor. Enter your travel info and vaccination status to check if any additional restrictions apply, such as testing or quarantine. It's important to also reconfirm the advice with official government websites as well as your travel insurance provider.
How much is the cheapest flight to Fire Island?
The next trip you take doesn't have to cost a small fortune. Within the last seven days, the cheapest roundtrip flight to Fire Island cost CA $134. Find your ideal fare and spend the dollars you save on amazing experiences. This price was available on Travelocity for flights to Fire Island departing within the next year. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.
If I cannot travel due to COVID-19, can I change my booking to a later date?
Our Customer Service Portal link has information about amending your flight due to COVID-19. Before locking in your tickets to Fire Island, it's a good idea to check the terms and conditions of your chosen airline too.
What is the cheapest month to fly to Fire Island?
If you're thinking about a vacation in Fire Island, September is the cheapest month to hop on a plane. This is according to Travelocity's direct return flight demand from January to December last year. Work out your ideal dates and secure your seat today.
How can I check my flight status to Fire Island?
Whether you want to view the status of your flight to Fire Island or make some changes, you'll find all the important details on our customer portal, Trips. Click on "Trips" at the top right of our homepage, then sign in or create an account. Another easy way to access and manage all your bookings is with the Travelocity app. Get real-time notifications about your flight and easily share updates with any friends or family flying with you.
How do I find the best deals on flights to Fire Island?
An easy way to find the best deal is to be flexible with your travel dates. First, search for your flight to Fire Island, then click on the "Flexible dates" box at the top of the page. This will let you see the prices for nearby days. Like another tip? Book early. To give you an idea of costs, CA $134 was the lowest price for a return flight to Fire Island in the last seven days on our site. This price was available on Travelocity for flights departing within the next year. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.
Why should I book my flight to Fire Island with Travelocity?
Pack your suitcase and get set to jet off with Travelocity. We'll help you locate impressive deals on cheap flights to Fire Island. Whether you want flexible airfares with plenty of room to move or cheap family flights from budget airlines, we'll make it happen.
What are the most popular flight routes to Fire Island?
Whether you have plans for a quick getaway or a marathon vacation, Travelocity can help you find your perfect flight to Fire Island. The leading flight routes to this destination include:

  • Los Angeles, CA (LAX-Los Angeles Intl.) to John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) - 6,404 flights a month.
  • London (LHR-Heathrow) to John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) - 4,693 flights a month.
  • Miami, FL (MIA-Miami Intl.) to John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) - 3,856 flights a month.

How much is a flight to Fire Island on average?
Based on prices found over the last seven days, roundtrip flights to Fire Island cost between CA $134 and CA $1,311. When you're ready to take off, Travelocity will help you find a fare to fit your budget. These prices were available on Travelocity for flights departing within the next year. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Plane Tickets To Fire Island

Although you may try and resist the urge, you know that when the travel bug comes, there is only one way to get rid of it. Thankfully, Travelocity is here to help nip that travel bug in the bud with great deals on flights to Fire Island. Browse through our inventory to explore a wide range of cheap flights to Fire Island to solidify your next big trip out of town. Whether you are heading out on a business trip, exploring a place you have never been for pleasure or are bringing the family on the annual vacation, we have the perfect getaway waiting for you. In no time, you will be day dreaming of your plane landing in Fire Island as you anxiously await to exit the plane and explore what Fire Island has to offer. Considering all the amazing local food and culture in Fire Island, we won't hold this against you.

When you are ready to embark on your next big adventure, Travelocity will be right here waiting to open the doors to the garden so that you can go and smell the roses. When you decide to book and travel is entirely up to you, but don't wait too long because we have some of the best deals on the web and they won't last long. Take time to go through our huge selection of cheap flights to Fire Island to find the best deals that fit into your budget. If browsing on your phone while your boss isn't looking is more your thing (we promise we won't tell), consider checking out Travelocity's mobile app which allows you to take advantage of all our flights to Fire Island without having to compromise your work computer's search history. If you are looking to save even more, you can easily save up to $537 when you bundle one of our cheap flights to Fire Island with one of our hotels. So why are you waiting around? There is no better time than now to start booking that next trip. Start your search now to book one of our flights to Fire Island today!

Explore More Ways to Travel with Travelocity

*Price based on the lowest price found within past 24 hours and based upon one night stay for two adults over the next thirty days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.