STARFISH BAY â live on the water in the heart of the Abacos. Step outside and the Sea of Abaco stretches to the horizon in every direction. Starfish Bay is a luxury threeâbedroom oceanfront home built directly on the water in a private gated peninsula at the tip of Marsh Harbour. With over 2,000 sq ft of outdoor decks, a protected dock in a private marina, and stairs that lead straight into the sea, this is island living at its finestâdesigned for families and friends who want space, comfort, and the ocean at their feet. Rated 4.94 with 17 reviews and an Airbnb Guest Favorite badge. Guests consistently praise the expansive outdoor living, the dock, and the central location.
THE HOME Starfish Bay was purposeâbuilt for luxury waterfront living and completed in June 2022. Bahamianâstyle exposed ceilings and an openâplan layout create a home that feels grand yet relaxed, with every main room oriented toward the sea.
Interior highlights: 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with high ceilings throughout Master bedroom with king bed, premium hemp linens, and large sliding doors opening directly onto the covered patio with unobstructed ocean views Guest bedroom 1 (waterfront) with queen bed and sliding doors to the patio and ocean view Guest bedroom 2 (garden view) with queen bed, separate A/C, large closet, and plenty of storage Openâplan kitchen, living, and dining area flows to the outdoor spaces through multiple large sliding doors Wellâstocked kitchen with gas range and griddle, fullâsize refrigerator and freezer, dishwasher, standalone ice maker, air fryer, coffee machine, toaster, blender, and electric kettle 50" smart TVs in all bedrooms and the living room with Hulu, Netflix, Amazon Prime, and more Sonos and Bluetooth speakers for streaming your personal music Large closets and generous storage in every room Highâspeed Starlink WiFi reaches every room, patio, deck, and dock
OUTDOOR LIVING â THE HEART OF STARFISH BAY The outdoor living at Starfish Bay is exceptional. With three distinct zones totaling over 2,000 sq ft, your group will spend most of their time outside and never feel crowded.
Zone 1 â Covered porch (~600 sq ft): Large sliding doors from the master, living room, and waterfront guest room open onto a spacious covered porch. This is the transition space between indoors and outâshaded, breezy, and furnished for lounging. Perfect for reading, napping, or escaping the midday sun while staying close to the action.
Zone 2 â Upper deck (~1,000 sq ft): The main event: a massive uncovered deck with infinity ocean views in every direction. Furnished with four cushioned chaises, four Adirondack chairs, an outdoor dining table that seats six, and a highâtop table for four. A cornhole set is always out for friendly competition. A large outdoor A/C unit helps keep the covered areas cooler on hot summer days. This is where sunsets happen, dinners are shared, and memories are made.
Zone 3 â Lower deck with ocean access: Below the upper deck, a lower platform with wide stairs leads directly into the crystalâclear Sea of Abaco. An outdoor shower on this level lets you rinse off after swimming, snorkeling, or a day on the boat.
Outdoor kitchen: A full outdoor cooking setup sits on the deck levelâWeber gas grill, outdoor sink, and prep counter. Grill todayâs catch, prep sides, and serve everything without leaving the waterfront. The chef stays part of the group.
Hammock: Strung on the upper deck, the hammock is a guest favoriteâsway in the sea breeze with a direct view over the water.
Water toys launched directly from the lower deck: 4 watercraft (mix of kayaks and standâup paddleboards) Large floating water mat Snorkel gear (fins, masks, snorkels) for up to 6 guests Wide deck and stairs make launching easy, even for younger guests All water toys are also available for use on the marina/canal sideâgiving you a protected, calmâwater option when northerly winds make the ocean side choppy.
YOUR PRIVATE DOCK & MARINA Starfish Bay includes access to a private, protected boat slip in our onâsite marina for vessels up to ~60 ft. The marina is located on the calm canal between the property and Sugarloaf Cayâa southâfacing waterway that provides sheltered dockage in most weather, including strong northerly winds that can make other docks in the Abacos uncomfortable or unsafe.
Dock amenities: Reverse osmosis fresh water at the dock 30âamp and 50âamp shore power Comfortable Adirondack chairs and shaded seating area for relaxing Fishâcleaning stationâclean your catch steps from your boat A completely different water view from the marina side: southâfacing over the Sugarloaf Canal and lagoon with spectacular sunsets
The marina gives your stay a second waterfront. While the house faces north over the open Sea of Abaco, the dock faces south over the protected canal. Two different experiences, two different viewsâand you have access to both. Whether you bring your own boat, rent one locally, or simply want a quiet spot to sit and watch the boats go by, the marina is always yours to enjoy. Please inquire about dockage at the time of booking. No liveaboards.
OFFâGRID LUXURY â POWER & WATER Starfish Bay is part of a selfâsufficient private property. You will never worry about power outages or water qualityâa genuine concern at many Abaco rentals, but not here.
Solar power plant provides reliable 24/7 electricity. Two diesel generators stand by as backup only. This is a true âgreenâ power systemâyou are staying at one of the most sustainably powered vacation rentals in the Bahamas.
Rainwater harvesting collects and stores fresh water onâsite. Reverse osmosis and a quadruple filtration system with UV treatment ensure every faucet delivers clean, drinkable water. No need to buy bottled water.
Highâspeed Starlink satellite internet delivers fast, reliable WiFi to every corner of the propertyâindoors, on every deck, and at the docks. Stream, video call, or work remotely without interruption.
PRIVACY, SECURITY & EXCLUSIVITY Starfish Bay sits within Eastern Shores, a private gated peninsula at the very tip of Marsh Harbour. Water surrounds you on nearly every sideâthe Sea of Abaco to the north, Sugarloaf Cay channel and lagoon to the southâcreating a uniquely private and scenic setting.
Gated community entrance with private road access Ring security cameras monitor the road entrance and marina onlyâno cameras inside the home or in any private spaces Quiet, upscale residential neighborhood ideal for walking, jogging, or simply enjoying the peace Your home has its own private parking, entrance, decks, and ocean accessâcompletely separate from any other structure on the property
THE MOST CENTRAL LOCATION IN THE ABACOS Unlike rentals on the outer caysâwhere you are confined to one small island and dependent on ferriesâour location on the main island of Great Abaco, at the hub of Marsh Harbour, gives your group unmatched flexibility to explore by land and sea.
By water (approx. from your dock): Hope Town / Elbow Cay â 3.5 miles ManâOâWar Cay â under 3 miles Mermaid Reef (snorkeling) â 1.5 miles Lubbers Quarters / Tahiti Beach â short ride south Fowl Cay National Park â nearby Montage Cay â less than 1 mile across the bay; a 53âacre private island being developed as a luxury Montage resort (inn, spa, deepâwater marina, and multiple dining venues) that you can see from your deck Treasure Cay â ~20 miles north Green Turtle Cay â ~20 miles north Little Harbour / Peteâs Pub â to the south
By land (from Starfish Bay): Marsh Harbour Airport (MHH) â minutes away Alburyâs Ferry Dock (Hope Town, ManâOâWar, Guana Cay) â less than 1 mile at the entrance to Eastern Shores Maxwellâs Supermarket and Price Right grocery â minutes Liquor store, pharmacy, clinic â minutes Local restaurants â minutes Boat Harbour Marina (fullâservice with fuel, diesel, and restaurants) â ~1.5 miles by car or boat
Marsh Harbour is the hub of the Abacosâthe airport, main supermarkets, ferries, and essential services are all here. You get the privacy of a waterfront estate and the convenience of being minutes from everything. A rental car is recommended for getting around and exploring the mainland. Taxis are always available at the airport.
BOATING IN THE ABACOS The Abacos are widely regarded as one of the best boating destinations in the world, and Starfish Bay puts you at the center of it all. The Sea of Abaco provides naturally protected waters between the outer barrier cays and the mainland, creating ideal conditions for day trips in every direction.
From our dock you can: Islandâhop to Hope Town, ManâOâWar, Great Guana Cay, Green Turtle Cay, and smaller cays Access offshore and bonefishing grounds Anchor at pristine, uninhabited beaches and sandbars Snorkel coral reefs and underwater parks like Fowl Cay Visit Tahiti Beach on the southern tip of Elbow Cay Cruise to Peteâs Pub at Little Harbour for a waterside lunch Reach Treasure Cay and Green Turtle Cay to the north for extended day trips
Being centrally positioned on the Sea of Abaco means you avoid long openâwater crossings. Day trips in every direction are short, safe, and enjoyableâeven with children aboard. If you plan to rent a boat, we strongly recommend booking earlyârentals fill up fast in peak season. If bringing your own vessel, please provide details when requesting your booking so we can prepare your slip.
ACTIVITIES FROM THE PROPERTY You do not need to leave Starfish Bay to have an incredible day on the water: Swim directly off the deck into the clear Sea of Abacoâsea turtles, starfish, and tropical fish are regularly spotted in front of the house Snorkel along the shoreline with the included gear Kayak or paddleboar
This house was absolutely perfect for our family. The layout of the house and all the amenities plus the dock for a boat made it truly special. Roland was awesome to help us with anything we needed. We made many wonderful memories here.
We had a fantastic stay! The home was beautiful, spotless, and exactly as described. Communication was seamless from start to finish. Roland was on-site and incredibly helpfulâalways available for any questions or needs. Our kids (6 and 4) absolutely loved chatting with him each day, which made the experience even more special. We truly canât say enough good thingsâan unforgettable week!
I'm difficult to impress, especially when it comes to rentals, but this exceeded my expectations. As we know, many rentals photograph well, but don't live up to that expectation. However, this property exceeded that standard. The dock was great, probably one of the best condition wise I've stayed at in the Abacos unlike some in treasure. House was great, well furnished with air fryer etc. Will definitely stay again if we come back to the abacos.
Everything you want for your Abaco stay, boat dock right there, personal ice maker , AC , sunrise and Sunset off the back deck , hermit crab races, good electric and water- never a glitch. Excellent kitchen and outdoor grill. It was actually much better than I deserved in the Bahamas.Easy access to airport - no ferry needed!
This is a really special property. The house is absolutely spotless and sits directly on the Sea of Abaco with a huge deck just steps from the water and perfect for enjoying the views. It is incredibly well managed by two wonderful people who strive to make your stay memorable. We could not have asked for a better place to stay while looking for our own property in the Abacos. Thanks again to Brandon and Lucy for making our stay so enjoyable.
What an amazing place and dock! Could not have asked for a cleaner, more spacious, inviting, well supplied accommodation with a spectacular view. Thank you Roland for helping with our requests and support for the week. We enhanced friendships and created some very special memories that will last a lifetime. Thank you Brandon and Lucy for hosting such a spectacular place.
Iâve spent a ton of time in the Abacos and the location and layout of this property is amazing. You have a calm channel to keep your boat docked in and the ocean in front of your house for snorkeling, paddle boarding and relaxing. The location is also perfect to island hopping. Itâs a great getaway for families or solo travel because itâs private and safe. I will definitely be rebooking this property as soon as possible. Also, the owners and the caretaker of the property are super responsive and really helpful. Five stars all the way.
First off everything that was portrayed in the listing is spot on as it appears. The property was in pristine condition and absolutely beautiful. To have Roland there to get what we needed along with any problems ( which there werenât any);to fix was a blessing and he was such a pleasure to have around. Contacting the owners when needed during the process of booking and what to expect was speedy and professional.
I would recommend this property to ANYONE and we will be booking again here shortly. Thanks for a wonderful vacation .
Louie M
As a renter of vrbos for over 20 years, it's hard to get me to rave about something. But Starfish Bay was truly one of the best houses we have ever stayed at. Brandon and Roland (property manager) were fantastic - super responsive, helpful, and accommodating.The house itself was perfect, really perfect. One of the best equipped kitchens we've ever had (and great cooking on the grill over the sea!) All furnishing and the house were new - and gave you the luxurious feel of a high end resort.We used the dock slip and rented a boat for the week - it was amazing along with the ice from Roland every day and the fish cleaning station on the dock.At the end of each day, sitting on the massive deck over the sea was the best - watching turtles, rays, and dolphins while we read or played games or just relaxed int he sun. Truly and amazing experience!!
By far the best VRBO we have ever stayed in. The hosts have thought of everything. You will not find a nicer, cleaner, better appointed VRBO in the Bahamas.
We enjoyed the breathtaking views from the oversized deck every morning and evenings. The protected dockage was ideal mooring for our boat. The location was perfect for exploring all the Abaco Cays via boat each day.
Communication and accessibility with the house manager was easy. He was extremely helpful and courteous everyday.
We will definitely return to Starfish and Mermaid Cove often.
Thank you Brandon and Lucy for sharing your home and little piece of paradise with us.
The property, host and caretaker (Roland) was amazing! The property was extraordinary, and Brandon was nothing short of a tour guide. He was so helpful. Please listen to his suggestions. It made our trip! It is a lovely property. The deck area was fabulous. I used it as a personal office for several days. The views are incredible. We loved our stay. We are considering our vow renewal at this property. #stunning! Roland was also a gem. You get what you pay for. It was so well stocked. It is amazing! Book it! The photo is right off the dock. Unreal. Thank you, Brandon and Lucy!
I've been fortunate enough to stay in a few 5-star homes/resorts... Starfish Bay far exceeds any of them. The attention to detail and all the amenities is beyond expectations. Every detail has been attended to. The place is immaculate, and the view is nothing short of spectacular. The outside deck is expansive. Lusea and Brandon were in communication making sure we had everything we needed and providing suggestions on activities. They have a caretaker on site who was very attentive and just pleasant to talk with. If there was a higher rating than 5 stars, I would have given it on this review.