6/10 Okay
Tom D.
May 18, 2026
Disliked: Cleanliness
Overall, we enjoyed our stay in McGaheysville and appreciated the excellent communication with the property manager. They were responsive, and easy to work with. The location within the Massanutten Resort area was great and very convenient to James Madison University. The kitchen was well equipped, and the dining area was spacious and perfect for gathering as a group.That said, the property itself appears to need some attention and general maintenance. The house overall seemed somewhat neglected, and the interior could really benefit from fresh paint, as the walls were pretty beat up. Unfortunately, the housekeeping/cleanliness was disappointing. The bathroom shower stalls and floors appeared dirty, stained, and worn. We also loved spending time on the deck, but the outdoor furniture was stained and dirty. Additionally, the gas grill was extremely filthy upon arrival, and it took about an hour to clean before it could be used for cooking.Another disappointment was that the main floor bedroom and the owner’s suite did not have suitable places to hang clothes, which was not ideal during our stay. We also felt the photos used in the property listing were clearly outdated and did not accurately reflect the home’s current condition. In addition, the driveway is on an extremely steep slope/hill, which could make navigating to and from the property difficult for anyone with physical limitations or mobility concerns.
Tom D.
Stayed 3 nights in May 2026