Book a hotel near Cayuga Lake, New York

"What an interesting and beautiful place! We were in Aurora for a family wedding, with relatives spread throughout the village—including several staying at the Inn. Of all the accommodations, those who had the pleasure of stopping by "the church" couldn’t stop raving about it. Many agreed it was an incomparable treasure that truly outclassed every other place.The owners have done a remarkable job reimagining this 1870s church. The bathrooms are beautifully updated—one even includes a luxurious steam shower. The kitchen is fully stocked with everything you could possibly need. Bedrooms are spacious, and the beds are incredibly comfortable.The photos in the listing are accurate and enticing, but the real thing far exceeds expectations.One note of caution: the property is not handicap accessible."

"Their home made granolas bars they leave for breakfast are amazing and they have gluten free options!"

"Large, clean home with a beautiful view of Cayuga. Lots of room for our extended family and a short drive from the Inns of Aurora where we attended a wedding. Large property with lakeside grill and fire pit. Nicely appointed kitchen and very comfortable beds. Would stay there again!"

"Booked for a quick weekday getaway in Aurora. The place was fantastic and Matt was a great host! "

"Experience was awesome and we enjoyed every second!"

"The house is amazing and the managers were always quick with their help and responses to our questions. We hope to stay again!"