Book Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island

"Took a chance for last minute spring break getaway the pictures looked really nice and I have to say in person was actually better than the pictures! You really never know what you are going to get and this case I really felt we got better than what was listed. We stayed for an overnight but we definitely be back for two to three nights in September. Staff was so lovely, the grounds are beautiful, clean and well kept. You cannot beat this view, room was spotless and had everything a family of four could need but most of all I appreciated the clean and updated furniture. The hotel offers a shuttle in to town that we did not need but I can see how in the summer would be really helpful. Indoor pool was open until 9pm with a lifeguard, our kids has a blast swimming after visiting the lighthouse and having dinner. There was a cute playground by the lighthouse our kids really enjoyed after touring the lighthouse itself. The restaurant in the hotel was not open in the off season time but it was easy enough to take a ride in to town & grab coffee’s. There are coffee pots in the room but you would need to bring coffee to brew and whatever you add to your coffee. My only suggestion for off peak season to the hotel would be a mini coffee bar in the lobby but honestly this hotel is perfect otherwise. Families & couples will love it here there is something for everyone. I really don’t right reviews but other people’s reviews helped me book this so paying it forward."

"The staff tending the front desk / bar were amazing, very friendly and helpful! "

"Our room was near the front desk and we could hear conversation and phone calls. "

"Yes, we found everything we needed."

"room was clean and fresh. staff ere helpful and accommodating."

"Bathroom very clean. Staff is super friendly. Ate at the restaurant and it was delicious. "