Book a hotel near Fire Island Lighthouse, Bay Shore

"We had a Fantastic time for our vacation weekend at the Crazy Coconut. The house is beautiful and everything is updated and brand new. The hosts were very friendly and so easy to communicate with. We hope to return many times and felt like welcomed guests as opposed to renters using the property. Highly recommend and Incredible view of the bay!"

"We enjoyed our stay on Walnut Street. Steps from the ocean beach and the bay. The house is very beachy and tidy with lots of light. The location is great and we enjoyed biking to the light house and taking a (long) walk to Ocean Beach and eating at Rachel’s for breakfast. Fire island is a magical place and this was a great house to enjoy it!"

"my family and i had a great time at the house on fire island. so close to the beach. and even without A/C, the breeze keeps the house cool and comfortable. Everything you could need was available. "

"Perfectly appointed home just steps from the beach, a great trip to fair harbor!"

"Ideal location in Fair Harbor! Beautiful beaches, sunsets and slower pace the minute you get off the ferry. House has all the essentials including fabulous outside shower along with plenty of rainy day games and reading activities. We had a great stay! Michael was a great host, providing helpful info ahead of trip and accessible during our stay as well. Check-in/out could not have been easier"