Book Club Quarters rooms in Lower West Side

"The hotel was great overall, and the location was excellent. However, I was disappointed to be charged a $50 early check-in fee even though our room was already ready. I wasn’t sure why we were charged that, but overall, it was a nice experience."

"Great stay"

"Breakfast was excellent and a ton of choices. I especially liked the oatmeal with cinnamon milk."

"Did not look like the pictures shown online old hotel not update"

"CONS: stayed in room 808. super dark, only had low lighting, which my partner and i suspect was so they could hide the stains of the room. view was of the ugly back side of the building. worst part was the ac/heater. it was cold when we were there in early may and we were told the heater wasn't working for any of the rooms, so we had to double up on blankets. had splitting headache during our first night and asked the front desk if they had tylenol (acetaminophen) which being the most basic of medications we thought they would have, but of course they didn't. husband had to do a cvs run at 2am for something they should've already had as a hotel. walls were thin that you could hear next door occupants flushing or taking a shower. lastly, very little water also came out of showerhead. PROS: great location (within a few minutes walk to starbucks reserve, trader joe's, and most importantly to the red line), price is cheaper compared to most hotels in the area. overall, hotel works only if your budget is tight. but if you want a truly restful vacation where you're not dreading going back to the hotel, then i'd recommend finding somewhere else to stay."

"Very nice, wish there was a pool area Great location Very nice staff "