6/10 Okay
Brian
Nov 11, 2025
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, room comfort
Overall, cabin was clean and comfortable, however, there were some areas for improvement. First, check-in was smooth, but it was unclear where exactly the cabin was located by the listing. It's 10 miles away on the other side of Plymouth from the Common Man Inn, just a mile and a half outside of town. The great thing was it was steps away from the Italian Farmhouse, which was excellent! Cabin was great and had a hot tub, which came as a surprise. Kitchen was well stocked, beds were comfortable and clean, and the gas fireplace made the living space very cozy. On the negative side, we noticed water bottles throughout the cabin - kitchen, both bathrooms - and came to realize that the water had a strong sulphur smell, so we used the water provided to brush teeth, make coffee. Showering was a little awkward with the smell of the water. The tvs in the living room an the smaller bedroom worked fine, but the one in the main bedroom only got one channel. Finally, we were told we could just leave the key and call the front desk - not have to go back to the main location. However, the phone in the room didn't work, so we ended up going back to the main inn to check out.
Again, the space was cozy and generally clean (minus the strong smell of the water) - loved the fireplace and hot tub - and the restaurants at both sites were probably the best in Plymouth. The cabin could use some TLC though.
Brian
Stayed 2 nights in Nov 2025
